Why do people do that?

Why the Happiest Life Isn’t the Most Meaningful One

A guy on a beach with nothing to do, or a nurse pacing a hospital hallway at 3 a.m. Which one's living the more meaningful life?

Make your free Worldview card

Worldview card

Eight tradeoffs where both sides sound right. Pick where you land on each. You get a map of how you see things, and a reading of what it says about you.

paullinehan.co/worldview

The Climb

The Climb comes out every Thursday. New videos go in it too.

Newsletter Sign-up Form

One email a week. Unsubscribe whenever.

Read the transcript

Picture a guy on a beach, he's got a little drink with an umbrella in it, nothing to do and nobody needs anything from him.
By basically every measure, he's happy.
Now picture a woman at 3 o'clock in the morning.
She's pacing a hospital hallway in yesterday's clothes, she's holding a vending machine coffee that tastes like burnt something and waiting to hear whether or not her dad's surgery went okay.
She is not happy, not even close.
So which of them is living the more meaningful life right now?
Yeah, you probably already know and that should bother you a little because most of us have built this life of ours trying to be that beach guy.
Here's this kind of quiet deal that we've all signed.
A good life is a happy life and happy means winning and sad or stressed means something's broken and needs fixing, right?
So you buy that thing or you take the trip, you delete the app, download a different app and maybe journal about your feelings in that notebook that probably cost $40 because it had gratitude on the cover.
The assumption underneath all of it is simple.
If you stack up enough good feelings, eventually have a meaningful life, right?
Kind of like a vending machine for your soul, happiness goes in and meaning comes out.
Unfortunately though, somebody actually checked to see if that was true.
So, a group of researchers led by a psychologist named Roy Baumeister ran a big survey.
They asked questions to people, two different questions that sound like the same question.
How happy are you and how meaningful does your life feel?
Now if happiness and meaning were the same thing, those answers would basically kind of move together, right?
Happy people would feel like their lives meant a lot and miserable people just wouldn't.
So to be fair, the two did overlap but just not nearly as much as you think.
Once the researchers dug into what went along with each one, the two of them started looking a lot less like twins and more like roommates maybe just doing it for the rent money.
Here's the first weird part.
Getting what you need and want went along with being happier, of course that makes sense, right?
You're hungry, you eat a burrito, you feel good.
You want a nap, you take a nap, life is great.
But getting what you want and needed had pretty much nothing to do with whether or not your life felt meaningful.
Now think about how weird that is.
You could get everything you want, every single item on the list and your life wouldn't feel any more meaningful for it.
You'd just be a very satisfied person with this nagging feeling you can't explain.
And so now it gets weirder.
Happiness went with being more of a taker and meaning went with being more of a giver.
And so sit with the uncomfortableness of that for a second.
That feeling we chase the hardest, the one every ad and every vacation brochure promises us, showing up next to taking.
Getting your needs met, getting your share, getting yours, all that.
The other thing, the one we say that we want at funerals and graduations and speeches, that one shows up next to giving.
So the stuff that costs you, like if you've got to drive your buddy to the airport at 5 o'clock in the morning, or maybe sitting through your kid's recorder concert, which probably sounds like four minutes of a smoke alarm arguing with a doorbell.
You don't do that because it feels good, because in the moment it really doesn't.
You do it because it matters.
And apparently those are two different things.
And so now, here's where it gets really uncomfortable.
More worry, more stress and more anxiety seemingly went with a more meaningful life.
And a less happy one.
Read that again.
The people who felt like their lives meant the most were on average more stressed out.
They worried more and felt more anxious.
Which when you think about it, I guess is kind of obvious.
Nobody's lying awake at night thinking about things that they don't care about.
You don't get anxious about some stranger's fantasy football team, you get anxious about your kid, about your marriage, maybe about that business that you sank your savings into and all the people that are counting on you.
Worry is basically the bill that comes when you care about anything.
The beach guy has no stress at all because the beach guy has no stakes.
Nothing on that beach can break his heart except maybe running out of the little umbrella thingies.
Now, I've got to be straight with you because this is kind of where people take a study and run off a cliff with it.
This was a survey.
It found that those things went together.
It doesn't prove that stress makes your life mean more.
So, no, I'd say you can't fill your calendar with a bunch of panic attacks and call it a spiritual practice.
Picking a fight with your landlord is not going to give your existence some extra depth.
Stress isn't some protein powder you can scoop up into your life so you can bulk up on your meaning, you know?
But what the survey does do is line up with something most of us already know deep down and we keep trying to forget.
The stuff that matters most usually isn't the stuff that feels good while you're doing it.
So here's the trap.
If your only scoreboard is do I feel good right now, you're going to steer yourself away from almost everything that matters.
Kids are exhausting and relationships take a lot of work.
Building something in public and helping people, that means mostly failing and it's very inconvenient.
Every one of those things fails the do I feel good right now test on a pretty regular basis.
So you'll bail.
You'll quit that hard project because it's stressing you out.
You're going to pull back from that friend who's going through the rough patch because it's bringing you down or you're going to skip the thing that would have given your year a point to begin with because the couch was just right there and it just felt so much easier.
And then years later you'll have a whole pile of pleasant days, wonderful comfy days that don't really add up to anything.
That's just the ugly version of it.
A whole lot of what we call protecting our peace is just avoiding anything that could ever really ask anything of us.
So some practical stuff because I'm not just going to leave you sitting here feeling bad about your beach vacation.
One, stop using happiness as your only gauge.
Feeling good is great.
So yeah, enjoy the burrito, but it's a pretty shitty compass.
If you only ever check, does this feel good?
Maybe also start asking, does this matter?
Sometimes the answer to both is yes.
A lot of times the answer to the second one comes with a pretty bad stomach ache.
Two, notice what you're worried about.
Your worries are a weirdly accurate map of what you actually care about.
If you're stressed about something, there's a good chance it's because it matters to you.
So the question isn't how you're going to make the worry go away.
The question is whether or not the worry is worth having.
Three, give something that costs you.
Meaning went well with giving, and real giving does cost your time and money and comfort and your sleep.
Writing a check you won't miss, that's fine, but it's the giving that actually costs you that tends to feel like it counts.
Four, pick your stresses on purpose.
You're going to be stressed either way.
Life pretty much guarantees it.
So you can be stressed about stuff that matters to you or about the traffic and whether or not somebody liked your post.
It's going to be the same blood pressure but a very different return on investment.
Here's what I think ultimately matters.
We spend a huge amount of energy trying to feel good.
Most of that isn't wasted.
Feeling good is nice and I'm a big fan.
But the moments that people point to at the end of their lives as the ones that mattered almost never felt good at the time.
They felt like that hospital hallway, that 3 o'clock in the morning feeding, the hard conversation or the thing that scared the shit out of them that they just did anyways.
The beach is great.
Go to the beach.
Just don't confuse it with your life.
Your life is the stuff that's worth worrying about.