Why do people do that?

You’re Not Overthinking. You’re Under-Finishing.

What happens when a worry stops at the scary part? I work through the questions I use to finish the thought.

Notes and sources

The Climb

The Climb comes out every Thursday. New videos go in it too.

Newsletter Sign-up Form

One email a week. Unsubscribe whenever.

Read the transcript

Every night, a whole lot of grown-ass adults lie perfectly still in the dark and ask the ceiling a question, over and over, like it's gonna answer. Everybody's got their own version. What if I lose my job? What if this lump is something? What if she's thinking about leaving? What if I'm fifty and still doing this? News flash, the ceiling has never once answered. And notice where every one of those stops, right at the scary part. Nobody lies awake going, what if the doctor calls back and then I book the follow-up? And then I ask what my options are. Nope. We get to the scary part and we slam on the brakes and then we back it up and do it again, all night. I did it for years, mostly about money. And the worst part is, it felt pretty responsible. Like I was the one guy in the house actually taking things seriously. Everybody else is asleep and I'm up on night watch guarding a family from... a thought. But I wasn't solving anything. I'd ask a question and then I'd run from the answer every single night. And it actually gets dumber too. A psychologist named Tom Borkovec spent decades studying worriers. And what he found is that worrying takes the edge off of the fear. Just a little. Just enough that your brain goes, great, we're handling it. You are not handling it. You're lying in bed watching the first ten minutes of a disaster movie on repeat and refusing to see how it ends. And so you keep doing it because it kind of works. And the actual problem just ends up sitting there. Like a check engine light that you put the piece of tape over. So now though, I finish the thought. No app, no breathing exercises, just three questions. One, then what? Keep asking until you hit the bottom. And two, what's the first thing I'd actually do? And then three, can I do any of that today? So let's try it. I used the job one, but this one really works on any of them. What if I lose my job? Then what? Well, I freak out for a couple of days. I'd probably eat cold leftovers standing in front of the open fridge. Fine. Then what? I start calling people, right? I dig out that resume I haven't touched since it probably had an AOL email on it. And then what? I need to cover the bills while I look, right? And how long can I do that for? For a lot of people, I know the honest answer is probably just a few weeks. And yeah, that's a bit of a gut punch. But look at what just happened. A minute ago, that whole problem was this giant shapeless monster living in your ceiling. And now it's a math problem. And math problems are boring as shit, which is great because boring problems are usually the ones you can actually fix. Move some money around, maybe. Kill that subscription that you forgot you had. Text those couple of friends that you probably would have called anyways. So that way, when you finish the thought, one of two things happens. Either it actually ends somewhere you'd survive and you can finally go to sleep. Or it ends at a real gap and now you know exactly what you need to fix. And both of those beat the shit out of the ceiling. Because the thing is, if we're being honest, a lot of us don't really want the answer. The question is scary, sure. But the answer comes with a whole lot of homework we don't want. So next time a what-if shows up at two o'clock in the morning, don't just shove it away. But don't lie there marinating it either. Finish it. I don't think most of us are overthinking. I think we're actually under-finishing.